To online proctor or not?
There’s no “perfect” tool for proctoring, unfortunately, and the use of online software proctoring (particularly webcam monitored testing) can raise equity issues. NIU Center for Innovative Teaching & Learning has an article on proctoring pros and cons that gives a brief overview. Answer these questions of yourself before choosing to proctor:
- Will this test/exam/quiz show students’ skills, knowledge, or apply the outcomes for the course?
- No? Try an authentic assessment instead. Book time with an expert to help you rewrite your assessment!
- Yes? Go to the next question.
- Are the questions taken directly from the text? (rote memorization)
- No? Great, if your questions are applied, it is less likely that students will cheat.
- Yes? Go to the next question.
- Does it matter for external accreditation that the students take the test proctored?
- No? Go to the next question.
- Yes? Use a proctoring service, but make sure to set it up in the most equitable way by reviewing the things to know about Respondus or Honorlock and understand the requirements you’re asking of students and its implications.
- Are you assessing students in multiple ways?
- No? Go to the next question.
- Yes? You may not need to proctor because they can show their competency in another way.
- Is this a low-stakes quiz?
- ​​​​​​​No? Go to the next question.
- Yes? You may not need to proctor because students are practicing their learning and will show mastery on another assessment.
- Do your students have access to reliable internet and computer that supports proctoring software?
- ​​​​​​​No? Don’t proctor, use alternative methods.
- ​​​​​​​Yes? You can consider proctoring, but be sure to review the equity issues and pros and cons before doing so.
Authentic Assessments
- Authentic assessments are those that require higher-order problem solving and are not as easy for students to quickly look up solutions. Learn more here!
Methods to Dissuade Cheating (and no need to proctor!)
- Honor Codes
- Create a course-agreed upon honor code at the start of the term, tapping into student and collegial values
- Remind students of the honor code at the start of the test (verbally or written)
- Ask them to reaffirm it (Q1 of the test)
- Canvas Quizzes
- First question be an attestation to not cheat (see honor codes – above)
- Quiz banks/Item banks
- Shuffle answer
- Shuffle questions (new quizzes)
- One question at a time
- Create set times – when students look up answers, they take more time; by imposing a time-limit, you disadvantage students who do this
- Review “away from quiz” logs
- The Public Exam System: in this process, you pre-publish 70% of the exam and insert different scenarios or questions for the scenarios at the time of the exam. This minimizes what can usefully be shared and allows easy instructor permutations without rewriting an exam.
- Oral Exams: Consider asking students to answer one or more questions orally at random, to ascertain their knowledge and provide an opportunity for them to explain their thinking process.
If you’d like to explore other options or these in more detail, you can always connect with GRC's eLearning staff!
Repondus LockDown Browser
If you’ve investigated test proctoring at GRC, you’re likely familiar with this option! “Repondus” comes in two different versions – the “LockDown Browser,” which provides a secure browser during a test, and the “Respondus Monitor” version, which also uses a computer webcam to record and digitally monitor students as they test. eLearning has more information on setting up Respondus testing here.
Some things to know about Respondus:
-
It may not work with Chromebooks or laptops issued by local k-12 schools, depending on the school district (personal Chromebooks do not typically have issues)
-
The “Monitor” proctoring options you can choose as an instructor may require students to have a webcam set up on their computers, to have a space with no motion behind them, and no background noise to take a test successfully.
-
Review the settings and what you’re asking students to do, then be up front to students about the environment and tools they need to be successful.
Honorlock Test Proctoring
Honorlock is a service that provides virtual proctoring and does work with Chromebooks. Because Honorlock tests are more expensive for the college to administer ($10 per student/year), GRC requests that instructors only use Honorlock if online test proctoring with Respondus is not an option. Honorlock also comes with multiple options – the “BrowserGuard,” which provides a secure browsing during a test, and the “BrowserGuard and Webcam” version, which also uses a computer webcam to record and digitally monitor students as they test. More information on Honorlock from eLearning here.
Some things to know about Honorlock:
-
Renton School District does not allow any use of proctoring on their devices.
-
The “Webcam” proctoring options you can choose as an instructor may require students to have a webcam set up on their computers, to have a space with no motion behind them, and no background noise to take a test successfully.
-
Review the settings and what you’re asking students to do, then be up front to students about the environment and tools they need to be successful.
Panopto
Panopto can be used to record students as they take an exam. While these are not proctored by an outside party, you can see what occurs while the exam is being taken. Doing so requires the student have access to a webcam and microphone, and the instructor will need to create an assignment folder in Panopto. More information on creating Panopto Assignment folders can be found here.
Some things to know about using Panopto with your students:
- Unlike Respondus and Honorlock, there is no flagging or other feature; Panopto would just be capturing a recording.
- The Panopto Recordings option must be activated in your course navigation for your students to be able to use Panopto to record themselves.
Where can students get help?
Respondus Direct
Honorlock Direct
-
Live chat during a test
Campus Support
-
Email (elearning@greenriver.edu) or call (253-288-3354) eLearning.
- The Holman Library has webcams available at the first-floor Circulation Desk for overnight checkout if students need as well as laptops that can be checked out by emailing circdesk@greenriver.edu.
-
In the past, there have been options for students to come into campus to use the testing center or other on-campus spaces when needing a “monitored” test if finding a space that met requirements didn't work, but please be aware these campus spaces are currently closed or very limited due to COVID.