Information Literacy

Scholarship as Conversation

Scholarship as Conversation refers to the idea that communities of scholars, researchers and professionals engage in ongoing analysis, discussion, critique and knowledge-building. New insights and discoveries build upon or in contradiction to existing knowledge. 

Objectives

Students should be able to:

  • Identify existing knowledge in a field and the contribution particular articles, books and other scholarly work make to disciplinary knowledge
  • Identify the ongoing conversation on a subject and step into that conversation at an appropriate level
  • Identify debate and disagreement
  • Seek out multiple perspectives
  • Think critically about existing knowledge in a field
  • Credit the ideas of others
  • Recognize that authority privileges some voices over others
  • Understand that knowledge is dynamic and evolving
  • See themselves as creators, rather than simply consumers, of information

Big Questions

Big Questions:

  • How can I participate in a scholarly conversation without merely parroting ideas?
  • How do I recognize a gap in information when I am not an expert?
  • How do I establish my own credibility on the subject?
  • How do our responsibilities shift when moving from mere consumers of information to critics and/or creators of it?

Video: How Library Stuff Works: Scholarship as Conversation

Source: "How Library Stuff Works: Scholarship as Conversation" by McMaster Libraries, is licensed under a Standard YouTube License.

Learn how students are active participants in academic conversation with their peers, instructors, and all those who came before them.